Committee recommended the legislature direct the DNR “to authorize sandhill crane hunting in Wisconsin.” This bypasses the normal decision-making by the Natural Resources Board.
Tim Eisele, Dave Clausen and Mark Martin
Special to Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
0:23
/
0:29
When the new legislature meets it should take recommendations of the Legislative Council’s Study Committee on sandhill cranes with a grain of salt.
The committee was established with the strong influence of the Wisconsin Waterfowl Association which is trying to stuff a proposal to hunt sandhill cranes down the throats of Wisconsinites.
The study committee included the association’s vice president, plus representatives of the corn and potato growers’ associations. It would have been a miracle if they did not favor a hunting season on sandhill cranes.
Committee stacked testimony and findings in favor of hunt
The committee took selected testimony from Wisconsin Waterfowl Association Executive Director Bruce Ross and put it in the form of a Summary of Findings, which not everyone on the committee supported. In addition, the committee:
•Failed to heed the comments of past DNR waterfowl ecologist Kent Van Horn who in August said that a hunting season in the fall is no guarantee it would help crop depredations in the spring. Van Horn also made it clear the decision to open a hunting season on cranes is a social decision.
•Heard from invited speakers only, and did not invite hunters against the season to express their views.
•Based their recommendation on the Constitutional amendment that guarantees the right to hunt, fish and trap in Wisconsin. That amendment does not guarantee open seasons on all species in the state.
Opinion:Wisconsin has stable and growing sandhill crane population. A hunt shouldn’t cause rancor.
Opinion:Sandhill crane hunting season isn’t a fit for Wisconsin. It would further divide us.
•Overlooked that the DNR has not recommended opening a sandhill crane hunting season in Wisconsin.
The committee passed a recommendation for the legislature directing the DNR “to authorize sandhill crane hunting in Wisconsin.” This bypasses the normal decision-making by the Natural Resources Board (NRB) to open a season.
Setting seasons by the legislature is bad precedent, which later can’t easily be changed and it (intentionally) bypasses the established system of opening hunting and fishing seasons by the NRB. The NRB is where biological and sociological justifications come together and where any decision should be made.
If they had any legitimate intent to do what was right for Wisconsin, they would have recognized that the current crop damage law is flawed. It pays crop damage fees for species that are hunted, theoretically justifying a hunt if farmers are to get reimbursed.
Wildlife belongs to everyone and that law needs to be amended so that damages are funded with GPR funds so everyone can pay for damage to crops.
Sandhill crane season will only further divide hunters and nonhunters
The question, whether a sandhill crane season should be opened is part biological, but the real question is sociological: why?
Why isn’t a sandhill crane season appropriate for Wisconsin? The answer is evident to many who read Aldo Leopold’s A Sand County Almanac: “The trumpet in the orchestra of evolution,” as Leopold described the call of Sandhill cranes, are special to Wisconsinites.
Opinion:‘Wisconsin Guarantee’ only assures that high school students fixate on grades
Letters to the Editor:I’ll take squawking over gunshots. Keep sandhill cranes off the kill list
Many surveys show that most citizens do not support a season. A season will only further divide hunters and non-hunters, when the opposite is needed. Hunting seasons differ from state to state. Look no further than Nebraska which has thousands of sandhill cranes and does not hunt cranes.
Not every state hunts every species, and Wisconsin does not need, and surveys show that a majority of citizens do not want, a hunting season on sandhill cranes.
Let’s bring hunters and non-hunters together so that both carry their fair share of funding for natural resources management, not further divide them.
Tim Eisele is a hunter and freelance outdoor writer/photographer. He has twice been the Conservation Communicator of the Year from the Wisconsin Wildlife Federation and he is a member of the Wisconsin Waterfowl Association. Dave Clausen is a life-long hunter, retired veterinarian and former Chair of the Wisconsin Natural Resources Board. Mark Martin is a hunter, member of Wisconsin Waterfowl Association, and wetland owner with nesting sandhill cranes. He was inducted into the Wisconsin Conservation Hall of Fame in 2023.
Actress Spills Hollywood Trick For Slim Body: “We All Do It”Here’s what Hollywood star Maggie Q does to achieve a balanced, healthy digestive system, all-day natural energy, reduced bloating and improved skin glow.Experts In Getting Slimmer|
Top Doctor: If You Eat Eggs Every Day, This Is What HappensThis Doctor has decided to release a short video to the public.Supplements and Wellness Resources|
Eat 1 Teaspoon Every Night, See What Happens A Week Later One Teaspoon Every Night Burns Body Fat Like Never Before, You Will Fit In Your Pants Again!Health Benefits|
Why Every Trainer Needs BlazePod in 2025BlazePod is changing the way athletes train. Boost performance with smart reaction lights that improve speed, focus, and coordination. Make 2025 your strongest year yet!BlazePod|
AdShop Now
Cardiologists: Add This 1 Thing To Your Coffee To Turn On Fat Burning ModeDiscover how a simple purple peel trick helps reduce stubborn belly fat effectively!Health Wellness Journal|
Washington Drivers With No DUIs Getting Paid on SundayWho Normally Has The Cheapest Car Insurance?FinanceAdvisors|
Top Cardiologists: Slim Down By Mixing This Into Your CoffeeHealth Wellness Journal|
AdWatch Now
7 Wealth Tips Once Your Portfolio Reaches $1 MillionFisher Investments|
AdLearn More
The best walking shoes are suitable for men to wear all day.Bestbestones|
AdShop Now
Flight Attendant Reveals How To Fly Business Class For The Price of EconomyCoupon Code Finder|
Deal of the Day
The Mary Poppins Bag Got An Upgrade: Save 39% On The Fit + Fresh All The Things BagUSA TODAY NETWORK
Save $50 On A Smart Device That Basically Brushes Your Child’s Teeth For ThemUSA TODAY NETWORK
Recommendations are independently chosen by our editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission.
Recommended
Outgoing Packers president/CEO Mark Murphy always valued team alumnisports
New Small Electric Car For Seniors – The Price May Surprise YouFavoriteSearches | Search Ads|
Doctors: Sleep Apnea Treatment Without CPAP (It’s Genius)Papmd|
More Local Stories
What started the wildfires raging across the Los Angeles area?news
All the celebrities who lost homes in LA firesentertainment
Charlie Berens gets kicked out of Milwaukee’s Central Standard in hilarious new video skitentertainment
Jocelyn Wildenstein, socialite dubbed ‘Catwoman’ dead at 84: Reportsentertainment
The Secret Trick That’s Slashing Fuel Consumption NationwideShopOptrimo|
AdClick Here
This Happens to Your Body When You Drink Almond Milk Every DayExperts In Getting Slim|
AdLearn More
Smart CPAP Users Swear By This For Mouth Leaks & Dry MouthPapmd|
7 Ways to Retire Comfortably With $1 MillionFisher Investments|
AdLearn More
More Local Stories
Teen killed in Waukesha crash remembered as ‘light to all who knew her’communities
Missing surfer likely dead in shark attack; man’s surfboard recoverednews
Donald Trump comments twice on death of former President Jimmy Carternews
MyPillow to pay DHL nearly $778,000 for lawsuit over unpaid billsmoney
More Stories
Trump discusses viral exchange with Obama at Jimmy Carter’s funeralnews
Why not use ocean water to fight LA fires? It’s not that simple.news
I received so many compliments while wearing this sweater.Made in USA|
Exposing the Big Game 
What? A “Sandhill Crane Hunt”??? No wonder our species is going INSANE!.