Big Cat Advocates Oppose Plan To Kill Cougars

Screen Shot 2015-09-28 at 3.17.20 PM

 http://www.eugeneweekly.com/20151008/news-briefs/big-cat-advocates-oppose-plan-kill-cougars

Oregon’s 2016 big-game hunting regulations will be on the agenda when the Fish and Wildlife Commission meets in Florence Oct. 8 and 9.

Specifically the commission will discuss opening up target areas where “cougar numbers will be proactively reduced in response to established criteria” for cougar conflicts with humans, livestock or other game animals such as mule deer.

There were no target areas in 2014 and 2015, but the commission is proposing to open up four areas in 2016. One of them is to reduce livestock and safety conflicts, two are for improving mule deer populations and the fourth is for mule deer and bighorn sheep.

Cougar advocates want the state to know that “the people of Oregon want cougars well managed and not killed en masse because of ill-conceived schemes that have no scientific validity,” as Scott Beckstead, senior Oregon director for the Humane Society of the United States, puts it.

In a call to Facebook followers to come and testify on Oct. 9, the group Predator Defense compares cougars to Cecil, the African lion killed by an American hunter, saying, “America’s mountain lions are experiencing the same fate as Cecil, Zimbabwe’s most famous and beloved lion, illegally killed in July by a Minnesota dentist on a trophy hunt.” The group continues, “But what’s happening here is even worse — the slaughter is legal and being carried out by government agents on behalf of deer hunters.”

Beckstead of HSUS tells EW, “The policy of treating wild ungulates like free-roaming livestock to be ‘harvested’ and wild carnivores as vermin to be exterminated is an archaic approach to wildlife management that ignores the evolving humane values of most Oregonians.” He points out that voters have opposed twice allowing recreational hunters to use hounds to hunt cougars in 1994 and 1996.

According to the commission’s agenda information, depending on the area, the cougar killing would be carried out by volunteer agents, federal Wildlife Services and the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife at an annual cost of almost $70,000 to remove 95 cougars. Sally Mackler, native carnivore advocate for Predator Defense, says “federal agents from the USDA’s Wildlife Services and local houndsmen deputized by ODFW are immune from state law banning use of hounds by trophy hunters.”

Beckstead says that “using packs of radio-collared trailing hounds and neck snares to indiscriminately kill Oregon cougars” in the target zones “under the guise of protecting mule deer and reducing conflicts with humans and livestock is just poor wildlife management, not scientifically valid.”

Mackler adds, “Science shows that cougar predation is a minor influence on mule deer population, and the main reasons for decline are habitat, nutritional quality of and access to forage.”

The groups are calling for a stop to “indiscriminate killing” and for the use of up-to-date science on the big cats, especially in light of the fact that Oregon’s management plan for cougars is due to be revised and updated next year. “Cougars should be conserved for all, not just managed for a few trophy hunters,” Predator Defense, HSUS and 10 other groups say in their comments to the ODFW commission.

Those who wish to testify about the plan can go to the 8 am meeting at the Driftwood Shores Resort, Pacific Room, 2nd floor, 88416 1st Ave. in Florence.

4 thoughts on “Big Cat Advocates Oppose Plan To Kill Cougars

  1. There are serious flaws in the “killing for conservation” thinking
    The biggest flaw is that we don’t truly understand humans are here because the non human beings who are on the earth are the participants in the very ” web of life”
    They are like a protective membrane covering the earth … Allowing it to remain fertile and healthy so we can live here as well …
    Cougars participate in activities like carbon sequestering and generate further activity amongst the wild for this very “web” to exist
    They allow the fertility of the soils and viabilty of the rivers to continue by their very existence
    For example, they monitor the ungulate populations that if out of control damage the riparian community and all its inhabitants and the rivers and WATER become compromised

    We who read this blog know the ramifications of annihilating species … We are living within a living breathing ecosystem and we should quite trying to override the system for greed
    Because we too will end up in the ” also ran ” pile
    A great book out right now ” invention of nature” about Alexandrer Von Humboldt ( Prussian scientist born in 1769) by Andrea Wulf points out the understanding of ecology systems and their interconnectedness… He understood even then how man’s greed was going to cause climate issues… And the demise of species that are part of the system
    We exist at the behest of that system
    The cougars are actually more important than us for the earth as they are “givers” to the system and we are “takers ” constantly removing resources and scraping away the very basics in the Web
    This is leading us to a very compromised position and jepodizing the very existence of all of life
    We may have a bigger brain but it’s not functioning properly if we don’t understand the very principles our existence is based upon.
    We can’t continue the ” take”( the pseudonym for killing )
    These non humans are actually the most precious resource managers doing their jobs in the wild for the earth … Leave them alone to do their job !

  2. Volunteer agents? Is that anything like Oxy Moron? Gah, I hate this trend of making something sound better than what it really is, it’s insulting.

    “For a small fee, I hereby deputize you Scummy McScumbag, Volunteer Agent!” *eyeroll*

    • So in other words, a hunter by any other name is still a hunter! I swear, if these people would expend half the energy on just doing the right thing from the start as they do on flim-flam – surely it would be easier? Volunteer agents, PR visits to Alaska, turning pages on our history with the Native Americans, deciding which animals are ‘lucky’ enough to accompany us on Noah’s Ark to sail into an uncertain future – just freaking do the right thing already!

Leave a reply to sharonstjoan Cancel reply